Carter Brady: Add To Cart
Carter Brady's “Add To Cart” Revisits Alternative Rock's Past While Searching for Its Own Identity
by Jack Rush
Nostalgia has become a reliable currency in contemporary alternative rock, but familiarity alone rarely guarantees artistic distinction. On Add To Cart, New York musician Carter Brady delivers 13 tracks indebted to the guitar-heavy traditions of the 1990s, presenting a record whose considerable instrumental ambition occasionally competes with its desire to establish a recognizable identity.
A continuation of his previous album, Shopping Cart, the project examines modern consumer culture and the tendency to measure personal fulfillment through accumulated achievements. It's a promising premise, although the relationship between that concept and the individual compositions sometimes feels more suggestive than fully developed.
“Relief” establishes the record's distorted, bass-driven character, while “Fake To Myself” draws heavily from familiar grunge conventions. “Home At 24” offers a more interesting structural approach, moving from restrained acoustic passages into aggressive instrumentation. The contrast demonstrates Brady's understanding of dynamics, even when the underlying stylistic influences remain conspicuous.
Elsewhere, “Idea Of Being Free” introduces lighter indie-pop sensibilities, and “Maturity” explores the territory between acoustic intimacy and expansive rock arrangements. These departures provide welcome variation, although the album's broad stylistic range raises questions about its overall cohesion.
Brady's extensive involvement in the recording process deserves recognition. However, technical independence and creative authorship are not necessarily substitutes for a distinctive artistic perspective.
At 13 tracks, Add To Cart might have benefited from greater selectivity and a more concentrated exploration of its central themes.
Nevertheless, the record demonstrates considerable dedication and musical versatility. Its greatest challenge is moving beyond the established sounds it so enthusiastically celebrates.
Have a listen and connect with Carter Brady:
